Meet the Cast of "The Play That Goes Wrong"!

Jonathan Arana*

Dennis; Perkins

Couldn’t be happier to be back with my friends at the Fulton after playing Sancho Panza in last season’s Man of La Mancha! Some career highlights include the 1st Nat’l tour of On Your Feet! alongside the Miami Sound Machine, performing at Carnegie Hall in Take Me to the World, On Your Feet! (Papermill Playhouse) The Drowsy Chaperone (Music Theatre Wichita) In The Heights (TUTS/Moonlight Amphitheater) The Andrews Brothers (Musical Theatre West/ Cast recording) and a cameo in Lin Manuel Miranda’s 2020 film “In The Heights” (don’t blink!) Thank you to Marc, Joey & this awesome cast & crew! @jonaranathan

E. Faye Butler*


Career spans over 40 years performing and directing plays and musicals; performing concerts, clubs, cabarets, regionally, nationally, and internationally. Recipient of nine Jeffs, two Helen Hayes, Ovation, Sarah Siddons, Excellence in Arts, Rosetta LeNoire, Kathy, Barrymore, After Dark, two Black Excellence, R.A.M.I., Guy Adkins, Heller & Haver Awards. Inducted into Women in the Arts, Lunt-Fontanne Fellow, and Chicagoan of the Year. She appears as Myrtle on HBOMax’s SouthSide.

Curt Dale Clark*

Chris; Inspector Carter

Curt has performed many roles here at the Fulton such as Captain Hook in Peter Pan, UPS Man in Legally Blonde, The Musical, Billy in Carousel, Harold Hill in Music Man, Javert in Les Misérables, Joe Gillis in Sunset Boulevard, Don Lockwood in Singin’ In The Rain, The Phantom in Phantom, Bob Wallace in White Christmas, Frank Butler in Annie Get Your Gun, Dr. Livesey in Treasure Island and the Tenor in The Irish… And How They Got That Way. He is from Pecatonica, Illinois and now splits time between Lancaster and Brunswick Maine where he is Artistic Director of Maine State Music Theatre.

Kevin Earley*

Robert; Thomas Colleymore

Fulton performances; Guys & Dolls & Wait Until Dark. Fulton Groff Studio Series Directing credits; Changing Channels, The Glass Menagerie, The Whipping Man* and coming this seasons, Who’s Afraid of Virginia Wolf. B-Way; Death in Death Takes a Holiday (Drama Desk Nom), Les Miserables, Thoroughly Modern Millie and Tale Of Two Cities. Directing; The Wonder, by Susan Ferrara, NY United Solo Fest Best Production, Co-Directed w/Julie Ann Emery) and The Fantastics at Webster Conservatory.

Nathaniel Hackmann*

Jonathan; Charles Haversham

Nate is thrilled to be back at Fulton! Portrayed Jean Valjean and Javert in Les Miserables on Broadway, as well as the titular roles in Jekyll and Hyde and The Hunchback Of Notre Dame. He has toured America in Beauty and the Beast and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. He appeared as Curly in the acclaimed production of Oklahoma! on BBC. Love and thanks to Nicole & Alexander!!! Twitter/Instagram @n8hackmann, he/him

Lara Hayhurst*

Sandra; Florence Colleymore

Lara is thrilled to be back at the Fulton Theatre, where she has previously been seen in Legally Blonde, The Wizard of Oz, Gypsy, and Hairspray. She has Broadway, Off-Broadway, Touring, and numerous regional credits. BFA Pace University NYC. Unending love to Marc, Joey, and the Fulton team. Thanks to Dave and her amazing roster of physical therapists. This one’s for Trey- her partner in this farcical, magical play we call life. Much more at and @larahayhurst. Champions Adjust.

Chuck Ragsdale*

Max; Cecil Haversham; Arthur

Appeared most recently at The Fulton in Murder on the Orient Express and is delighted to return with TPTGW. He has traveled the US (and Canada) with the Tony Award-winning First National company of A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder, and has appeared in multiple off-Broadway productions and principle contracts at numerous regional theaters. As an arts educator, he holds positions at CAP21 in NYC and The Warwick Center for Performing Arts in Warwick, NY. Big thanks to Marc, Joey, and WTG.

Davon Williams*


See him next as Whizzer in REP Stage’s FALSETTOS. NYCLU Artist Ambassador and 2x Anthem Award winner for the Actors’ Equity Association’s Nationally recognized Black Theatre Matters Bill. FULTON: 5 GUYS NAMED MOE, FOR COLORED BOYZ~International: DreamGirls (McCoy/Rigby), Festival of The Lion King (HKDL), TED Talk Alum~Regional: RAGTIME (Bay St.), GREY GARDENS (Center Theatre Group), OKLAHOMA (Weston), Porgy & Bess (ETC)~Film/TV/Other credits listed at

Cameron Wright

Crew; u/s Trevor & Jonathan; Charles, u/s Chris; Inspector

Cameron is thrilled to be back on the Fulton stage after appearing in The Man of La Mancha (Anselmo), Shrek (Shrek), and A Christmas Carol (Fred/Young Scrooge) last year. Born and raised in Maine, he has appeared in shows throughout the state, his favorites being with Maine State Music Theatre. Highlights include Godspell, A Grand Night for Singing, Tommy, Guys and Dolls, and Welcome Home. Much love to cast crew and everyone else involved for this bringing this hilarious production to Lancaster!

Sebastian Antonio

u/s Jonathan; Charles Haversham

Fulton Theatre debut! Local credits include: Jekyll & Hyde (Jekyll/Hyde), Beauty & the Beast (The Beast/Gaston), A Christmas Carol (Jacob Marley). Many thanks to Marc & Joey for the opportunity, as well as to everybody who has supported the journey up to this point. Go Birds!

Bailey Blaise

u/s Sandra; Florence

Recently at the Fulton: White Christmas. Favorite Utah Shakespeare Festival credits: Clue (Yvette), Trouble in Mind (Judy), Ragtime (Evelyn Nesbit), Julius Caesar (Portia/Octavius). Other credits: Arrow Rock Lyceum (Funny Girl, The Music Man, Oliver!), Musical Theatre West (Catch Me If You Can), Hunterdon Hills Playhouse (Sherlock Holmes Returns!), Rubicon Theatre Co. (South Pacific). Proud University of Alabama alumni – roll tide! Many thanks to Marc, Joey, & my family!

Raymond Marc Dumont*

u/s Cecil; Arthur; Max

Ray is so happy to return to the Fulton. He previously danced in Guys & Dolls in 2018. Ray spent many wonderful years with Maine State Music Theatre (21 seasons), as performer, director, choreographer, intern director, and even Managing Director. He has worked all over the country, performing such roles as Cosmo in Singin In The Rain, Lucky in Dames At Sea, and Mike in A Chorus Line. Thanks so much to Marc and Joey for this opportunity. Love to Josh, always!

Ron King*

u/s Jonathan; Charles Haversham

Fulton Theatre credit: Kinky Boots. Upcoming: Damn Yankees at Marriott Theatre. Past credits include productions with Marriott Theatre, Maine State Music Theatre, Paramount Theatre, Chicago Shakespeare Theater, Drury Lane Theatre, Milwaukee Repertory Theater, Forestburgh Playhouse, Riverside Theatre (Iowa City), Griffin Theatre, Theo Ubique Cabaret Theatre, and Emerald City Theatre.

Bryant Martin

u/s Robert;Thomas

Bryant is thrilled to be a part of “The Play That Goes Wrong”. Thanks to everyone at the Fulton, cast and crew for making such an awesome show!

Kelly J Mazzella

u/s Annie

Originally from PA, Kelly is thrilled to start 2023 back at the Fulton. She was last seen in the Sound of Music and Man of La Mancha. As well as Sherlock, Shrek and Sleeping Beauty with the Family Theatre series. Other credits include Spamalot (Lady of the Lake) at Arizona Broadway Theatre, Pinkalicious with the Vital Theatre Company. Catch her next month in Jimmy Buffet’s Escape to Margaritaville at the Walnut Street Theatre. Kelly is a proud alum of the Boston Conservatory. Much love and thanks to Marc, Joey, my friends, family and husband Justin for your love and support. Xoxo

Mark Tinkey

u/s Chris; Inspector

Fulton debut! For Pittsburgh CLO: “A Musical Christmas Carol”, “Shear Madness”, “Forbidden Broadway: SVU”. Pittsburgh Playhouse: “Ah, Wilderness!”, “All My Sons”, “FBI Girl” (world premiere). Other credits include, “West Side Story”, “Evita”, “Joseph…Dreamcoat”, “Hunchback of Notre Dame”, “Jesus Christ Superstar”. TV: “Mindhunter”. Thanks to Marc and Joey for this incredible opportunity.

*Members of Actors’ Equity Association, the union of professional actors and stage managers in the United States.