Last 5 Years Cast

Carrie St. Louis*

Catherine Hiatt

Broadway: Kinky Boots (Lauren), Wicked (Glinda), Rock of Ages (Sherrie). National Tour: Wicked (Glinda), Rock of Ages (Sherrie). Off Broadway: Titanique (Rose), Cruel Intentions (Annette). Regional: Legally Blonde (Elle), The Fix (Deborah). TV: “The Good Fight” (Paramount+), “Elementary” (CBS), “Blindspot” (NBC) and “Younger” (TV Land). A graduate of USC’s Thornton School of Music, Carrie is also an esteemed vocal coach with a private vocal studio in NYC. @carriestlouis

David Toole*

Jamie Wellerstein

a Pittsburgh native, making his debut at the Fulton! Recent regional theater credits; “Count of Monte Cristo,” “Great Comet of 1812,” and “Once”, a featured vocalist performing alongside Jason Robert Brown in concert at the CAM Raleigh and collaborating with Frank Wildhorn at the Tuachan PAC. Outside of theater; an anthem singer for the Pittsburgh Penguins’, certified voice instructor, and vocalist for Identity X & Streetlight Amber. Gratitude to Jesus, Katie, Barrett, and Elijah.

Madison Paige Buck

u/s Catherine Hiatt

Thrilled to be back at the Fulton, working on a dream role! BA in Musical Theatre and Opera from Temple University. Fulton credits: 9 to 5 and Les Miserables. Regional credits: Cosette in Les Miserables (ARLT), Pattie in Beehive (VA Repertory Theatre and Prather Productions), Emma in Jekyll & Hyde (Prima), Lead Singer at American Music Theatre and Fireside Theatre. Endless gratitude to Marc, Joey, and the Fulton team, and love to her family and Ben.

Tobias Kaj

u/s Jamie Wellerstein

Washington State-born actor, Tobi is thrilled to be making his Fulton Debut! Regional: Sight and Sound (Samson, David, Moses, and Daniel) . Other Credits: Into the Woods (Cinderella’s Prince), Life Could Be a Dream (Skip), and Children of Eden (Cain). Film Credits: Letters to Freedom (Gabriel). God is so good! Much love to my beautiful wife and daughter for their love and support. Gratitude to my family, friends, and fellow creatives. Excited to be joining the Fulton Fam!